Will SCOTUS uphold ban on child transgender surgery?
Watch the Dershow on Youtube, Rumble, Spotify and Apple.
Discussion about this post
No posts
© 2025 Alan Dershowitz
Substack is the home for great culture
Watch the Dershow on Youtube, Rumble, Spotify and Apple.
No posts
Your summary "hired as a man, fired as a woman" is wrong, Alan. Your client wasn't a woman. Your client was a cross-dressing man. You can argue he should have a right to wear a dress and heels, but arguing that he "is a woman" is factually wrong.
And that really is the core of the trans issue today. Because if a man can actually become a woman by putting on a dress (or taking hormones or getting surgery), then SHE must be treated in law, in every respect, as a woman. If, however, a man who does those things is simply a man playing a fancy game of dress-up, HE can be treated with kindness but still excluded from female spaces.
The issue of intersex / hermaphrodites is not relevant to this. That's not what's going on here. The law deals with sex (not gender) discrimination and there are only 2 sexes in all mammals.
BTW: I listened to this argument live: https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/live.aspx Not sure why you didn't.
Kids should be removed from parents that are a harm to them.